News

TCE worries homebuyers

Couple backs out after disclosures mention toxics under E. Evelyn

The level of toxics in the groundwater under a new Shea Homes development is low, by northeastern Mountain View standards. But at least one local couple has backed out of a purchase nonetheless, citing particular concern over TCE there.

The 150-unit row home development known as "Mondrian" at 505 E. Evelyn Ave. is currently under construction. Its three-bedroom homes are priced at around $600,000, and appeared to be a good deal to the Zimmermans, a young newlywed couple.

"Well-priced three-bedroom homes in Mountain View are hard to find," Elaine Zimmerman wrote in an e-mail.

The Zimmermans put down a deposit and were given a week to look through a 150-page binder full of information, fill out forms and gather the necessary records. At the last minute, they found a page in the binder mentioning the toxin known as trichloroethylene, or TCE. After some Google searching, the couple found a Web site describing TCE as highly carcinogenic, and decided the low-priced home wasn't worth the worry.

With comparably sized new homes in the area going for $900,000, "We decided that $300,000 is the price of your health," Elaine Zimmerman joked.

Don Hofer, vice president of Shea Homes Northern California division, says the Mondrian homes are not at all dangerous. But he added that potential buyers unhappy with that or any aspect of the homes shouldn't buy them.

"We have full Department of Toxic Substances Control approval of the site for housing and it's very safe," Hofer said. "In regards to homebuyers that canceled, that's why we disclose these things. If they aren't comfortable with the situation they probably made the right decision for all of us."

The City Council approved a rezoning of the area, from general industrial to medium density residential, in April 2006. That decision gave Shea Homes the green light to design the complex, which later received city approval.

Real or imagined

Numerous epidemiological and lab studies on the health effects of TCE are compiled in a 2006 report from the National Academy of Sciences National Research Council. Some studies indicate that TCE causes human fetus development problems and might cause congenital heart defects. Other studies say it may be linked with Parkinson's disease. Inhalation of TCE fumes also can have neurological effects, the report says, such as slowed reflexes. Various forms of cancer also were cited as possible side effects.

Though the groundwater concentrations are much lower than at other housing sites in the city, such as at Whisman Station, Elaine Zimmerman was still concerned.

"Is it worth freaking everybody out? I don't know," she said. She worries that others may not be as diligent as she was in reading all of the fine print. "I just think of all those other couples I saw" touring the homes.

Soil and groundwater contaminated with TCE are a common phenomenon in northeastern Mountain View. Just north of the Mondrian project is Whisman Station, a 503-unit development built on the site of a former GTE operation which used TCE as a solvent. After construction, 40 homes were tested in 2004 for toxic TCE vapors, which can come up through the soil and into the air above. One home was found to have unacceptable levels of TCE in the air -- a problem which could have been caused by a tear in the special membrane developers installed in the foundation during construction.

The leak was mitigated by installing a ventilation system. Other Whisman Station homeowners did not allow the EPA in their homes.

Test results

At Mondrian, the source of the TCE is likely a small building once located at the center of the site that was used to store "significant quantities" of hazardous materials for semiconductor wafer manufacturer Pacific Western, which occupied the site after 1979. The 1962 building's first tenants were Memorex and the Carburundum Company. Less toxic VOCs such as PCE and DCE were also found on the site, along with low levels of the pesticide DDT, evidence of the vineyard and orchard uses there before 1962.

Analysis of groundwater samples at the northwestern edge of the site showed no connection with the TCE plume at Whisman Station.

One way to determine the risk of vapor intrusion is by measuring groundwater concentrations. Maximum concentrations at Mondrian are 21 parts per billion, versus over 100 parts per billion at Whisman Station, says Mountain View resident Lenny Siegel, director of the Center for Public Environmental Oversight.

"Chances of a vapor intrusion problem at Mondrian are probably lower than Whisman Station, but they can't be dismissed without more data or mitigation and follow-up sampling." Siegel said in an e-mail.

But Hofer says Shea Homes will not have the indoor air tested in the homes after construction. A sealing layer under the cement slab foundations, or "sub-slab membrane," is already being used at a "substantial cost," to prevent vapor intrusion, Hofer said, even though levels were not high enough for it to be a requirement.

Red tape

The Department of Toxic Substances Control, which usually is in charge of air quality at a site, has classified 505 E. Evelyn Ave. as "no further action required," after a "voluntary cleanup agreement" was completed in 2006.

This was troubling to Siegel, who pointed out that the 21 parts per billion of TCE found in the groundwater at Mondrian is four times higher then the remediation goal the EPA is using at other Mountain View sites, such as Moffett Field, where 5 parts per billion is the goal of a major TCE plume cleanup.

After contacting a dizzying array of agencies, including the EPA, the state Department of Toxic Substances Control and the Regional Water Quality Control Board, the Voice was unable to determine if any government agency was working to clean up the site's groundwater. A spokesperson from Toxic Substances Control referred the Voice to Nathan King, the water board's project manager for a nearby site at 303 Ravendale Ave. King could not be reached by press time.

RESOURCES:

* The Department of Toxic Substances Control and the Regional Water Quality Control Board have searchable databases here and here

* An environmental impact report for 505 E. Evelyn Ave. can be downloaded from the city's Web site; a discussion of toxics begins on page 80

* The Academy of Science's TCE human health report summary is available here

Comments

Posted by rem, a resident of another community
on Mar 9, 2009 at 12:32 pm

Why don't we have a honest City Council that will honestly say "Developer (Contractors) Lobbyists , Developer (Contractors), "donate to us and we will approve"!!!!"

It would be great if the City Council and all the other "Councils" and "Work Shops" learned a new word – NO or new phase – DISAPPROVED….

There is no sane reason for this PROBLEM except MONEY, MONEY, MONEY and not caring about the people of Mountain View or ANY of the other communities …..

Sound to me like DEVELOPMENT, DEVELOPMENT, DEVELOPMENT !!!! Gee, the CITY has messed up so much without looking back and LEARNING from the past..

Like I said ABOVE – "There is no sane reason for these PROBLEMS except MONEY, MONEY, MONEY and not caring about the people of Mountain View or ANY of the other communities….."


Posted by resident, a resident of Whisman Station
on Mar 9, 2009 at 10:36 pm

So that's why my baby was born with two heads!!!


Posted by Realist, a resident of another community
on Mar 12, 2009 at 5:42 pm

At only 21 µg/L, the TCE concentrations in groundwater are only a problem if you drink the groundwater. Vapor intrusion is not a concern. To those who disagree, I've got a $300,000 bridge to sell you...


If you were a member and logged in you could track comments from this story.

Post a comment

Posting an item on Town Square is simple and requires no registration. Just complete this form and hit "submit" and your topic will appear online. Please be respectful and truthful in your postings so Town Square will continue to be a thoughtful gathering place for sharing community information and opinion. All postings are subject to our TERMS OF USE, and may be deleted if deemed inappropriate by our staff.

We prefer that you use your real name, but you may use any "member" name you wish.

Name: *

Select your neighborhood or school community: * Not sure?

Comment: *

Verification code: *
Enter the verification code exactly as shown, using capital and lowercase letters, in the multi-colored box.

*Required Fields

Palo Alto quietly gets new evening food truck market
By Elena Kadvany | 3 comments | 2,735 views

On Tour - The Highly Selective Liberal Arts Colleges: Occidental, Pitzer, and Scripps
By John Raftrey and Lori McCormick | 1 comment | 1,701 views

See Me. Hear Me. Don’t Fix Me.
By Chandrama Anderson | 2 comments | 1,484 views

Questions for Council Candidates--Housing
By Steve Levy | 24 comments | 1,262 views

Rock N Roll Green Beans
By Laura Stec | 0 comments | 941 views