Sign up for Express
New from the Voice, Express is a daily e-edition, distributed by e-mail every weekday.
Sign up to receive Express

Login | Register
Sign up for eBulletins
Click for Mountain View, California Forecast
Voice News
Increase font Increase font
Decrease font Decrease font
Adjust text size

Tension eases for El Camino
LAFCO board 'accepts' audit critical of hospital, but says ECH is making progress

Bookmark and Share
For the time being, the El Camino Hospital District is not in danger of being dissolved by the county agency charged with regulating the health care municipality.

The board of the Santa Clara County Local Agency Formation Commission voted Aug. 1 to accept the final draft of a critical independent audit of the hospital and to formally request that El Camino officials take action to improve governing practices and increase transparency, while simultaneously acknowledging that the health care organization is well on its way to making those improvements.

Members of the LAFCO board chose their words carefully during the Wednesday afternoon meeting, noting that while the county agency was "accepting" the critical report the board had no intention of moving forward with the most extreme sanction in their power -- dissolving the hospital district -- at least not any time soon.

"My feeling was that, well, they're trying -- they've made progress -- let's keep working to continue on that path," said Margaret Abe-Koga, one of the LAFCO board's five members, in an interview with the Voice the day after the Aug. 1 meeting. "We don't need to discuss dissolution."

For the past year or more, according to El Camino officials, the hospital administration and district board members have been working to make it easier for the public to understand the health care organization's inner workings, finances and to draw a sharper line between the hospital corporation and the hospital district. Abe-Koga and other members of the LAFCO board said these efforts have not gone unnoticed.

"They did come out looking like they did a very good job," Abe-Koga said.

"We're very pleased," ECH spokeswoman Chris Ernst said immediately following the vote. "It's reaffirming of all of the great work that we do."

Indeed, the chairman of the LAFCO board, Pete Constant, said he has no doubt that El Camino Hospital offers high quality care to its patients. In fact, Constant noted, he had recently been treated at the hospital and was very impressed with his experience.

The quality of care delivered by El Camino Hospital was never in question. Rather, it was the hospital's governing and financial practices, which have come under fire. First, a June 2011 report from the Santa Clara County Civil Grand Jury critiqued the El Camino for not drawing a clear enough distinction between the money it collects as a private corporation versus the money it collects from taxpayers through the hospital district. That report prompted LAFCO to commission an independent audit from the public sector management consulting firm Harvey M. Rose Associates, LLC.

The first draft of the Rose audit, delivered to LAFCO on May 23, came to similar conclusions as the civil grand jury report and made a series of recommendations for LAFCO to consider, including pushing for greater transparency in governance and accounting. If the hospital did not make those changes, the audit recommended that LAFCO use its powers as a regulating agency and take measures to force the hospital district's hand. The most extreme of such measures, the report noted, would be to dissolve the district.

However, beginning last year, in the wake of the civil grand jury report, the hospital has made a concerted effort to make many of the changes the audit recommended. After the vote, Ernst noted that El Camino has created a new and separate website for the district, with its own URL address; hospital corporation and hospital district meetings are no longer held on the same night; and the hospital has changed the way it presents its budget in public board meetings to make it easier to understand. All these things, and more, Ernst said, have been done in an effort to make the hospital more transparent.

"Sure, there are areas to improve in terms of good governance, but they seem to be making an effort to do that," Abe-Koga said.

Are you receiving Express, our free daily e-mail edition? See a sample and sign-up for Express.


Comments

Posted by randy albin, a resident of the Cuesta Park neighborhood, on Aug 2, 2012 at 2:56 pm

first, make health insurance affordable to pretty much everybody. obamacare? the whole health insurance debate is pretty difficult in the u.s.a. many patients and people have been helped at el camino hospital over the many years. make it a top-notch hospital for really good patient care in such a manner as to not bankrupt the patient


Posted by Old timer, a resident of the Blossom Valley neighborhood, on Aug 2, 2012 at 5:35 pm

Randy, when I was a young kid, back in the mid-20th century, healthcare was affordable.

Congressmen taxed income on the "rich" so much that nobody wanted to get a pay raise since all their extra pay would go to the IRS. Corporations counterattacked the IRS by offered tax-free benefits, such as "free" health insurance to recruit top talent.

Soon, everybody wanted "free" health insurance. Doctors charged more because the "wealthy" insurance companies could afford to pay it. Soon, malpractice lawyers smelled money and a doctor's malpractice insurance bills went sky high. Next, insurance companies took months to pay the doctors, so doctors had to hire more people to beg the insurance companies for the money owed them. The American Medical Association is a trade union (same as the Teamsters and Auto Workers) whose only goal was to make doctors wealthy. "Big Pharma" is the drug companies who charge exorbitant fees and only push drugs which can be patented, thus enriching the drug companies and their stockholders (i.e., you and me). The pill you pay $10 for sells in Tijuana for 12¢, and in Canada for 28¢. Your congressman (and his lobbyists) make this legal and mandatory.

Most health conditions are preventable and easily corrected through diet, exercise and nutrition. You can't patent good health practices, so there is no profit motives in it.

Now don't make me explain it again!


Posted by LovingMtnView, a resident of the Old Mountain View neighborhood, on Aug 12, 2012 at 7:55 pm
LovingMtnView is a member (registered user) of Mountain View Online

Hey Old timer...

I did not realize that free health insurance was offered by corporations to employees to get around paying income taxes. That is really interesting and I'm going to read further on the subject.

I do understand why "The pill you pay $10 for sells in Tijuana for 12¢, and in Canada for 28¢." Big Pharma is a global operation and they look to recoup research expenses in the most optimal way possible. Mexico pays 0.12, because that is what they can afford. If they charge $5, then the pharma companies will make less revenue overall. Canada pays 28 cents, because they have nationalized health care and will only pay a certain amount. That leaves the United States that is so worried about being labeled with the McCarthy era Socialist label, that health care is privatized.

Unfortunately, the "free market" does not work very well when you have Big Pharma with monopolies on patented life saving drugs and the consumer/buyer of the product unable to refuse paying whatever it takes to save or extend their lives. Health care is not like buying a TV. You can't just walk away from a pill that will save your life and go find another. You may be in extreme pain or looking at the end of your life. Most likely, you will pay.

The US will go to a form of nationalized health care--it is just a matter of time. How we consume health care will be different than it is today, but by spending less on it means that we will be more innovative. That's what I love about this country...we will persevere!


If you were a member and logged in you could track comments from this story.
Add a Comment

Posting an item on Town Square is simple and requires no registration! Just complete this form and hit "submit" and your topic will appear online. Please be respectful and truthful in your postings so Town Square will continue to be a thoughtful gathering place for sharing community information and opinion. All postings are subject to our TERMS OF USE, and may be deleted if deemed inappropriate by our staff
 
We prefer that you use your real name, but you may use any "member" name you wish.

Name: *
Select your Neighborhood or School Community: * Not sure?
Comment: *
Enter the verification code exactly as shown, using capital and lowercase letters, in the multi-colored box. *
Verification Code:   
 

mv-voice.com   ©2013 Embarcadero Media.
All rights reserved.