Holiday Spirit
Posted Dec. 24, 2020

CSMA's arts education moves from the classroom to online

by Erin Brownfield / CSMA / Contributor

Wen local schools and businesses closed their doors due to COVID-19 in March, the Community School of Music & Arts acted quickly to move its in-person art and music classes, lessons, camps and concerts to an online format.

"Many of our offerings could be presented online with little disruption. Faculty members received training in best practices for online teaching, and staff made some adjustments to the way programs were offered to be more compatible with a virtual format," said CSMA's Executive Director Vickie Scott Grove.

Indeed, the school has maintained a robust schedule of virtual arts learning and concerts throughout the pandemic.

A more challenging question, however, was how to continue serving the tens of thousands of students served by CSMA's Art4Schools and Music4School programs, which provide sequential, standards-based arts education in public schools -- and in many cases are students' only access to arts education. In Mountain View, these programs are supported by donations to the Mountain View Educational Foundation and offered in partnership with the Mountain View Whisman School District.

According to Art4Schools Program Manager Jennifer Mineer, "We have been so impressed by the hard work and innovation that our incredible teachers and school partners have put forth to continue art and music education for students who are learning from home. Our district partners work tirelessly with us to address everything from scheduling needs to instrument distribution, and, as a result, we are able to seamlessly integrate arts education into students' online school day."

As a result, the Art4Schools and Music4Schools programs are bringing a dose of creativity to online lessons in every elementary school in the Mountain View Whisman District.

Two CSMA art teachers, Wendy Ron and Karla Navarro, describe what it has been like teaching online.

Ron, who teaches at Stevenson PACT Elementary, says that though she misses seeing students in person, virtual learning has its upsides. She has seen introverted students open up more since they can now type questions to her in the chat section of their screens and her younger students now "have no problem keeping their hands to themselves."

One of her favorite things about teaching online is seeing parents, siblings and pets join her classes.

"We are engaging with families right in their homes. Students are excited to share the art they have hung in their room or around their homes," Ron said.

She is happy to provide parents with a moment of peace: "I am grateful (parents) can rely on me to connect with their child in a meaningful way and to support them in a moment of need. That makes me feel really good."

Bilingual art teacher Navarro teaches at the District's Spanish immersion school, Gabriela Mistral. Her favorite teaching moments have been watching students' reactions to her lesson plans. She says her students "always have genuine, honest responses. Their expressions of excitement, wonderment and curiosity are so pure."

Despite the occasional technical hiccups, she finds satisfaction in teaching online "knowing that it's (my students) on the other side of the screens eagerly waiting for me."

Navarro's favorite lesson is teaching fourth graders about California missions using line, contour and perspective. In the process of teaching this art lesson, Navarro ensures her students learn about land acknowledgment and the Native American experience around the missions.

"Art is my favorite subject," said Mistral fourth-grader Nicolas P. "I look forward to Friday (lessons) all week. I like how Ms. Karla tells stories about the history of art while she teaches us. She's a great teacher, who's very kind to kids and knows a lot about art and all the things behind it."

Make a donation
2021 Recipient Agency

Community Health Awareness Council
CHAC serves Mountain View, Los Altos, Los Altos Hills and seven school districts. Among the services it offers are schoolbased counseling and programs to protect students from high-risk behaviors.

Community School of Music & Arts
The Community School of Music and Arts provides hands-on art and music education in the classrooms of the Mountain View Whisman School District.

Community Services Agency
CSA is the community's safety-net providing critical support services for low-income individuals and families, the homeless and seniors in northern Santa Clara County, including Mountain View, Los Altos and Los Altos Hills.

Day Worker Center of Mountain View
The Day Worker Center of Mountain View provides a secure place for workers and employers to negotiate wages and work conditions. It serves workers with job placements, English lessons, job skills workshops and guidance.

Mayview Community Health Center
The MayView Community Health Center in Mountain View offers primary care services to low-income and uninsured patients in northern Santa Clara County. No patient is turned away for inability to pay for services, which include prenatal and pediatric care, cancer screenings and chronic disease management.

Mentor Tutor Connection
Mentor Tutor Connection matches adult volunteers who serve either as mentors with under-served youth in high school or as tutors to students in elementary and middle schools in Mountain View and Los Altos school districts.

YWCA of Silicon Valley
This group operates a 24-hour bilingual hotline and a safe shelter for women and their children. It also offers counseling and other services for families dealing with domestic violence.


As of January 12, 2020
137 donors have contributed $79,010 to
the Mountain View Voice Holiday Fund.
* indicates amount withheld

19 Anonymous6,645
Anne Johnston150
Ellen Wheeler50
Kathleen Cutler*
Bruce Karney500
Edward Perry200
Kathleen & Sergey Bonte150
Tom & Barbara Lustig*
Thomas J. Mucha350
Michael A. Tugendreich200
Robert Rohrbacher*
Margaret Chapman100
Heather Cowper100
Patricia Larenas500
Sally B. Evans500
Ed Taub108
Jeanne Elam200
Linda Catura1,000
Marilyn Gildea100
Herbert Perry100
Herta Schreiner100
Diana Hall50
Daniel Kelly1,000
Emma Wong500
Leslie C. & Anita N. Nichols*
Catherine Howard150
Melissa Jankowski150
Jill Bertrand300
Lori Abrahamsohn50
Jeff Segall & Helen He200
Kevin & Robin Duggan*
Norma Jean Bodey Galiher200
Jim & Alice Cochran700
Lyle & Sally Sechrest100
Brian & Marilyn Smith*
Susan Elliott Russell1,000
Wesley D. Smith*
Andy & Liz Coe100
Crystal Chow200
Paul & Sarah Donahue2,000
Erik & Ankita Kaulberg*
Elizabeth Swierk200
John Baya & Rose Han250
Kathleen Creger500
Kristina Sandoval100
Gary & Yuko Kushner*
Josh Switkes & Meg Kelly1,000
Kevin & Laurel Smith1,000
Judy Atterholt & Chris Petti100
Randa Mulford250
Lora Henderson50
Vivi Naumovski100
Samantha Knox100
Feng Zhou8,000
R. Lanier Anderson &
Katherine A. Preston500
Robert & Lois Adams500
E. Denley Rafferty100
Gail Nyhan & Dave Offen*
David Fung*
Sarah Campbell100
Janet Jarmann30
Ross Heitkamp350
R D Roode150
Kanan Krishnan250
Ellis Berns100
Janet Sloan & Peter Stahl2,000
Donna Davies800
Dianne Chambliss700
Karen Skold100
John Igoe100
Patricia Hayes100
Leona K. Chu*
Pamela Baird1,000
Julie Steury & Peter Reynolds500
Sherleen Ong500
Scott Haber50
Sheri Morrison*
Laura Blakely100
Jon Burns250
Marilyn & James Kelly100
Cliff & Kara Chambers1,000
The Burtin Family*
Jeral Poskey250
Christopher Chiang*
Michael Kahan150
David & Karen Keefer200
Randy Robinson200
Karen DeMello100
Joel Riciputi*
Ann Kapoun200
J Steury500
K. Hayes Family2,000
Sara Jenez*
Bruce Lin1,337
Steve Attinger500
Yiping Liao150
Ronald Nakao50
Max Beckman-Harned700
Diane Nanis50
Sanna Wager500
In Memory Of

Mack & Laila Holombo400
Ken & Arlene Christie100
Jim & Sally Haydn-Myer200
Dori400
Ernesto Alejandro*
Judith Manton50
Eva D Chang200
Michael Van De Vanter50
Mark Flider*
Jennifer Murray50
Christopher & Mary Dateo500
Dr. Sofia Laskowski200
In Honor Of

Jane & Gerald King500
Tyler Beatie50
Ed, Petros & Thalia185
As a Gift For

Glen & Linda Eckols200
Businesses & Organizations

Hewlett Foundation8,750
Packard Foundation8,000
Wealth Architects2,500


Changes or corrections to listings may be made by contacting Kali Shiloh at [email protected]