Wells Fargo takes ownership of 1,800 EPA units

Bank becomes city's biggest landlord after foreclosure auction attracts no bids

Wells Fargo took ownership of more than 1,800 housing units in East Palo Alto's Woodland Park neighborhood Tuesday afternoon, officially becoming that city's largest landlord.

The bank's foreclosure auction for the properties, which were previously owned by Palo Alto-based firm Page Mill Properties, attracted no bidders Tuesday, said Elise Wilkinson, Wells Fargo spokesperson. As a result, Wells Fargo officially took ownership of the properties, which the bank valued at $142 million.

Page Mill has been vehemently criticized by its tenants and by city officials for repeatedly raising rents at the properties. Some have accused the company of "predatory equity" and demanded rent reductions. Page Mill had maintained that the raised rents are needed to fund security upgrades, seismic retrofits and other improvements at the properties.

The company is also embroiled in more than a dozen lawsuits with East Palo Alto over rent control at these properties -- lawsuits that the city officials hope to settle in the coming weeks.

Page Mill lost control of its properties last fall, after it defaulted on a $50 million balloon payment to Wells Fargo. In September, the company's property managers temporarily abandoned their buildings because the company had insufficient cash flow. A San Mateo County judge then appointed an overseer for the properties.

Wells Fargo said in a statement that it does not expect the auction results to have much impact on the building residents. The firm Investors' Property Services will continue to manage the properties, the bank announced.

"After speaking with many members of the East Palo Alto community and carefully weighing the options, we believe Wells Fargo's acquisition of these properties will provide the best possible outcome for the residents and the community," Wells Fargo Managing Director Sean Barlas said in a statement. "In the short-term, we expect little or no impact to tenants at Woodland Park Apartments or the community."

Chris Lund, a tenant advocate and leading opponent of Page Mill's rent hikes, said the bank's ownership of the properties comes as a "sigh of relief" for the tenants. He said Page Mill had spent about $269 million to buy up the properties.

On Tuesday, the prices for the opening bids for the housing units ranged from $323,079 for the property at 640 Circle Drive, to $17.6 million for the large apartment building at 1 Newell Court. Lund said he was heartened by the fact that the bank's opening bids closely reflected the building's value, not Page Mill's purchasing price.

"I think the bank genuinely wants to do the right thing," Lund said. "It has closed the Page Mill chapter and that's a positive thing for the community."

Wilkinson said the bank enlisted BRIDGE Housing Corporation, a leading affordable-housing developer, to help it consider long-term strategies for the properties. She said it's too early to tell if, when and to whom these properties would ultimately be sold.

"Together, we will thoughtfully look at what makes sense for the properties," Wilkinson said. "We'll take our time and look at all the options."

Lydia Tan, BRIDGE executive vice president, said in a statement that the first step will be gathering as much input as possible about community concerns and possible solutions. The group now plans to meet with building residents and other stakeholders.

"We are just starting our outreach, and we will be looking forward to connecting with all stakeholders through individuals as well as town-hall meetings," Tan said.

Meanwhile, the East Palo Alto City Council is looking to tighten up the city's rent-control ordinance to make it more consistent with state law. City officials also hope to clarify some of the language about allowable rent increases -- issues that prompted a flurry of lawsuits from Page Mill.

East Palo Alto officials were forced to cancel last year's attempt to revise the ordinance after a court challenge from Page Mill. Councilman Ruben Abrica said the city now plans to place the revised rent-control ordinance on the June ballot.

Abrica said the city has scheduled a public meeting on March 11 at 6:30 p.m. at City Hall to discuss revisions to the ordinance.

The City Council is also trying to negotiate a settlement over the glut of lawsuits filed by Page Mill over the past two years. A council committee discussed the long list of legal issues in a closed session Tuesday, said Abrica, a member of the committee.

Though Abrica alluded to several difficult "sticking points" in the negotiations, he said Wells Fargo's ownership of the properties would bring some welcome clarity to the process.

"At least, now it's clear who the owner is," Abrica said. "Now that it's clear that Wells Fargo is in control, the negotiations can be much more direct."


Like this comment
Posted by Richard Wicks
a resident of Jackson Park
on Mar 4, 2010 at 1:39 am

FIRST: Raising rents in EAST Palo Alto would be a good first step into making it non gangland territory anyhow.

Second: "no bids"? Well, that's simple to explain - there were no bids because Wells Fargo wouldn't allow the property to be sold at it's true market value which is the price it would have sold for if that were allowed. Nobody can make a profit buying these properties at the asking price.

Wells Fargo will soon discover that the property is worth a lot less, and all the property will fall into disrepair, because they won't maintain it, and Palo Alto won't challenge the bank on it. By the time this is all over, the properties will just be lots and scrubland.

Like this comment
Posted by Hardin
a resident of Cuesta Park
on Mar 4, 2010 at 3:26 pm

What's with Rent Control in East Palo Alto? The few examples of rent control in the Bay Area do not show intended or positive results for the communities that have them (ie San Francisco). Placing an artificial cap on rents discourages development and improvements.

And if the East Palo Alto City Council thinks dealing with Wells Fargo is going to be easier than the previous owners, they are in for a big surprise. Wells Fargo has the resources to be a tough negotiating party.

Implementing revised rent control measures ahead of dealing with Wells Fargo is either extremely naive or extremely foolish of the City Council. They are apt to received the same treatment from Wells Fargo a man dressed in a suit made of ribeye would get, if he walked into a cave with a sleeping bear.

Having witnessed the debacle of their school district and asinine actions promoting rent control, I'm concluding East Palo Alto's woes have little to do with their geographic location, and much more to do with mismanagement of the city.

Like this comment
Posted by caz
a resident of Rex Manor
on Mar 5, 2010 at 6:13 pm

Stupidity - the voters are stupid, yes the ones who voted for rent controls

Like this comment
Posted by cc
a resident of Shoreline West
on Mar 8, 2010 at 3:36 pm

High priced rent control buildings provide no incentive for new owner to maintain the place. As low income families are highly concentrated in one pocket area, bad things will happen. Can anyone name a slum with relative low crime in a city? I guess not.
Slum is like a cancer cell of a city, it grows bigger in time. When the good neighbors feel unsafe in the area, they would move out.

Posted by Name hidden
a resident of another community

on Sep 24, 2017 at 2:31 pm

Due to repeated violations of our Terms of Use, comments from this poster are automatically removed. Why?

Sorry, but further commenting on this topic has been closed.

Burger chain Shake Shack to open in Palo Alto
By Elena Kadvany | 19 comments | 5,044 views

The Cost of Service
By Aldis Petriceks | 1 comment | 1,232 views

Couples: When Wrong Admit It; When Right; Shut Up
By Chandrama Anderson | 0 comments | 770 views