News

Man in brazen 'home invasion' eviction scheme targeting Mountain View renters takes plea deal

Steven Carling pleaded no contest to assault with deadly weapon in March 2019 attack on Rock Street apartment

A San Jose man involved in a brazen apartment break-in intended to force out a family accepted a plea deal and awaits sentencing in March, according to court documents.

Steven Carling, 53, pleaded no contest on Jan. 23 to assault with a deadly weapon -- a felony -- as well as two misdemeanors for making criminal threats and attempting to prevent victims from contacting police. The three counts carry a maximum prison sentence of four years, and do not include a first-degree burglary charge originally sought by prosecutors.

Court minutes and the plea deal form show Carling has agreed to three years of formal probation as well as current time served as of Jan. 23 -- about five months. Prosecutors in the case did not immediately respond to the Voice's request for comment.

Carling was one of five people involved in what police described as a conspiracy to illegally oust renters from an apartment on Rock Street in August last year. Text messages between two of the suspects, identified as 50-year-old Reenu Saini and 49-year-old Lori Walston, detail how Saini sought to use the confrontation as a chance to "kick them out" or at least "scare them up a bit," according to an exchange transcribed by officers.

The apartment was occupied at the time by a married couple and two children, who had been living in the apartment for only a few weeks. During the attack, the family escaped through a back door and was found a short distance away on Rengstorff Avenue.

What's local journalism worth to you?

Support Mountain View Online for as little as $5/month.

Learn more

Saini allegedly coordinated the plans and arrived with the accomplices outside of the apartment on the evening of Aug. 26, and gave explicit instructions via text message to take the family's cellphones to keep them from calling the cops, according to a police report. Saini cut the power to the apartment, which she said could help "smoke" them out, according to text messages.

Carling's role in the operation was one of brute force: Police say witnesses and one of the accomplices -- a friend of Carling -- confirmed that he tried to force his way into the apartment by striking the front door, though the stories on how this was carried out differ. The friend told officers that Carling did not have any weapons or tools, and had knocked first to warn renters to get out of the way because he intended to kick down the door.

The victims painted a different picture, describing how Carling attacked the door and splintered the wood. At one point he began thrusting a knife through a crack, nearly stabbing the father of the family who was bracing the door from the other side. Police arriving at the apartment saw Carling still holding a metal object that matched the description of the knife, and officers say his actions amounted to assault with a deadly weapon.

Carling was released from county jail on his own recognizance on Jan. 23 on condition that he agree to appear in court for sentencing on March 20. He served a previous prison term after his 2012 conviction for felony possession of a stolen vehicle in Santa Clara County.

The case against Saini, who is accused of burglary and unlawfully turning off the apartment's power, is still ongoing, and she is due to appear in court on March 16 for a preliminary hearing. In an interview with the Voice last year, Saini defended her eviction attempt and described how she was a lessee of the apartment and rented the unit out to others for short-term stays. Up to the Aug. 26 break-in, she said she had been losing money because the renters had not been paying rent.

Stay informed

Get daily headlines sent straight to your inbox.

Sign up

Saini said she was seeking $10,000 in monthly rent for the two-bedroom apartment, significantly higher than the $3,900 the family claims it had originally agreed to pay.

Follow Mountain View Voice Online on Twitter @mvvoice, Facebook and on Instagram @mvvoice for breaking news, local events, photos, videos and more.

Man in brazen 'home invasion' eviction scheme targeting Mountain View renters takes plea deal

Steven Carling pleaded no contest to assault with deadly weapon in March 2019 attack on Rock Street apartment

by / Mountain View Voice

Uploaded: Wed, Feb 5, 2020, 10:28 am

A San Jose man involved in a brazen apartment break-in intended to force out a family accepted a plea deal and awaits sentencing in March, according to court documents.

Steven Carling, 53, pleaded no contest on Jan. 23 to assault with a deadly weapon -- a felony -- as well as two misdemeanors for making criminal threats and attempting to prevent victims from contacting police. The three counts carry a maximum prison sentence of four years, and do not include a first-degree burglary charge originally sought by prosecutors.

Court minutes and the plea deal form show Carling has agreed to three years of formal probation as well as current time served as of Jan. 23 -- about five months. Prosecutors in the case did not immediately respond to the Voice's request for comment.

Carling was one of five people involved in what police described as a conspiracy to illegally oust renters from an apartment on Rock Street in August last year. Text messages between two of the suspects, identified as 50-year-old Reenu Saini and 49-year-old Lori Walston, detail how Saini sought to use the confrontation as a chance to "kick them out" or at least "scare them up a bit," according to an exchange transcribed by officers.

The apartment was occupied at the time by a married couple and two children, who had been living in the apartment for only a few weeks. During the attack, the family escaped through a back door and was found a short distance away on Rengstorff Avenue.

Saini allegedly coordinated the plans and arrived with the accomplices outside of the apartment on the evening of Aug. 26, and gave explicit instructions via text message to take the family's cellphones to keep them from calling the cops, according to a police report. Saini cut the power to the apartment, which she said could help "smoke" them out, according to text messages.

Carling's role in the operation was one of brute force: Police say witnesses and one of the accomplices -- a friend of Carling -- confirmed that he tried to force his way into the apartment by striking the front door, though the stories on how this was carried out differ. The friend told officers that Carling did not have any weapons or tools, and had knocked first to warn renters to get out of the way because he intended to kick down the door.

The victims painted a different picture, describing how Carling attacked the door and splintered the wood. At one point he began thrusting a knife through a crack, nearly stabbing the father of the family who was bracing the door from the other side. Police arriving at the apartment saw Carling still holding a metal object that matched the description of the knife, and officers say his actions amounted to assault with a deadly weapon.

Carling was released from county jail on his own recognizance on Jan. 23 on condition that he agree to appear in court for sentencing on March 20. He served a previous prison term after his 2012 conviction for felony possession of a stolen vehicle in Santa Clara County.

The case against Saini, who is accused of burglary and unlawfully turning off the apartment's power, is still ongoing, and she is due to appear in court on March 16 for a preliminary hearing. In an interview with the Voice last year, Saini defended her eviction attempt and described how she was a lessee of the apartment and rented the unit out to others for short-term stays. Up to the Aug. 26 break-in, she said she had been losing money because the renters had not been paying rent.

Saini said she was seeking $10,000 in monthly rent for the two-bedroom apartment, significantly higher than the $3,900 the family claims it had originally agreed to pay.

Comments

The Business Man
Castro City
on Feb 6, 2020 at 1:39 pm
The Business Man, Castro City
on Feb 6, 2020 at 1:39 pm
7 people like this

YES.

I remember reading in the Palo Alto Daily News printed version about how the Landlords attorney claimed that the landlord was "justified" to take these actions based on some "false paperwork" the tenant provided to them.

That was the worst legal defense I could have imagined.

NOW This defendant is cooperating with the prosecution.

The landlord had better plea bargain, or it is looking at real jail time.


The Business Man
Castro City
on Feb 7, 2020 at 5:57 pm
The Business Man, Castro City
on Feb 7, 2020 at 5:57 pm
Like this comment

Boy no landlords are talking about this story.

Perhaps it is because it was totally inappropriate.

WHERE IS THE CITY COUNCIL ON THIS?


The Business Man
Castro City
on Feb 9, 2020 at 3:36 pm
The Business Man, Castro City
on Feb 9, 2020 at 3:36 pm
Like this comment

WHERE IS CURT CONROY ON THIS STORY?

WHERE IS JOHN INKS ON THIS STORY?

WHERE IS TE CAA ON THIS STORY?

WHERE IS THE RHC ON THIS STORY?

WHERE IS THE CITY COUNCIL ON THIS STORY?


The Business Man
Castro City
on Feb 9, 2020 at 3:37 pm
The Business Man, Castro City
on Feb 9, 2020 at 3:37 pm
Like this comment

WHERE IS CURT CONROY ON THIS STORY?

WHERE IS JOHN INKS ON THIS STORY?

WHERE IS THE CAA ON THIS STORY?

WHERE IS THE RHC ON THIS STORY?

WHERE IS THE CITY COUNCIL ON THIS STORY?


The Business Man
Castro City
on Feb 9, 2020 at 3:37 pm
The Business Man, Castro City
on Feb 9, 2020 at 3:37 pm
Like this comment

WHERE IS CURT CONROY ON THIS STORY?

WHERE IS JOHN INKS ON THIS STORY?

WHERE IS THE CAA ON THIS STORY?

WHERE IS THE RHC ON THIS STORY?

WHERE IS THE CITY COUNCIL ON THIS STORY?


The real businessman
Castro City
on Mar 30, 2020 at 12:49 pm
The real businessman, Castro City
on Mar 30, 2020 at 12:49 pm
Like this comment

This is Fake News. JFC.

I'm sorry. I retract everything. Please don't sue me for being a putz.

Sorry,

The Business Man


The Business Man
Castro City
on Mar 30, 2020 at 1:13 pm
The Business Man, Castro City
on Mar 30, 2020 at 1:13 pm
Like this comment

THe person above is trying to imitate me, he is not the registered poster.

It looks like he is trying to put words in my mouth, whish are nothing but a LIE.

I still demand:

WHERE IS CURT CONROY ON THIS STORY?

WHERE IS JOHN INKS ON THIS STORY?

WHERE IS THE CAA ON THIS STORY?

WHERE IS THE RHC ON THIS STORY?

WHERE IS THE CITY COUNCIL ON THIS STORY?


Don't miss out on the discussion!
Sign up to be notified of new comments on this topic.

Post a comment

Sorry, but further commenting on this topic has been closed.