"Three Billboards" has proven increasingly controversial and divisive, and not without good reason. The movie traffics in the institutional failures plaguing American police departments and their communities, making pointed reference to the injustices suffered by black citizens.
Frances McDormand stars as Mildred Hayes, the soul-scarred mother of a teenage girl raped and murdered seven months before the film begins. Roiling with righteous fury, Mildred hatches a plan to push for justice in the unsolved case: She pays for three billboards shaming the Ebbing, Missouri, police department. Proceeding from this turn-up-the-pressure premise — suggestive of the communal sensibilities and satire within ancient Greek plays — McDonagh positions himself to observe every pipe burst around the fictional small town (its ironic name suggesting the ebbing of the American empire and, with it, its moral authority).
In its most simple terms, "Three Billboards" is fascinated by what happens when raw emotion and intellect overcome reason. McDormand's unstoppable force meets movable object after movable object in an insatiable quest for satisfaction, and the actor's performance is pure perfection, squeezing every bit of pulp from the dialogue in ways that honor the character's humanity and each situation's black comedy. But McDonagh also determinedly sets up expectations about archetypal characters and then undermines them.
The approach first manifests when Mildred squares off with Chief Bill Willoughby (Woody Harrelson), and we discover that he's not easy to dismiss as incompetent or uncaring. He's also an object example of that old chestnut, "Everyone you meet is fighting a battle you know nothing about," which Mildred must acknowledge but deem irrelevant to her own cause. A less personal but not insignificant problem facing Willoughby is dimwitted Officer Jason Dixon (Sam Rockwell), who has a reputation for torturing black suspects. He, too, will turn out to be a more rounded character than he first appears, becoming more centered, smart, capable and generous of spirit than he would at first appear.
The evolution of Dixon's character turns out to be one bridge too far for the film. McDonagh's admirable shading of ostensible heroes and villains backfires in this case, despite Rockwell's witty and charismatic performance. Nevertheless, "Three Billboards" wickedly entertains and provokes, partly with shocking violence and political incorrectness, and partly in reckoning with the emotions behind America's civil violence. In McDonagh's world, we're all victims, and it's the rare victim who doesn't seek restitution by becoming a perpetrator himself.
Rated R for violence, language throughout, and some sexual references. One hour, 55 minutes.
This story contains 456 words.
Stories older than 90 days are available only to subscribing members. Please help sustain quality local journalism by becoming a subscribing member today.
If you are already a subscriber, please log in so you can continue to enjoy unlimited access to stories and archives. Subscriptions start at $5 per month and may be cancelled at any time.