When you view CI through a wider lens, you discover thousands of schools that give children power and choice in their education. Some, like Sudbury Valley School near Boston, are at the most progressive end of democratic education, giving children complete control and choice over their education.
Sudbury Valley has affiliates in 30 locations around the world, including one in Santa Clara, the Cedarwood Sudbury School. Peninsula School, another local school in Menlo Park begun in 1925 by Josephine Duveneck, provides a child-centered education community for the development of the whole child.
These schools have dramatic results. Students are passionate about their learning and their projects. Children of all ages treat one another and staff with honesty and respect. Children are eager to go to school. Creativity, problem solving and a natural love of learning flourish. Graduates start their own businesses and attend colleges of their choice.
Many people believe children cannot be trusted to know what is best for them. They believe the only way for a child to learn and grow is by adults teaching and telling them the important facts and lessons of life. As a family and education consultant, I've found that when you give children opportunities to make choices for themselves, they develop the essential life skills to be self-reliant and to create joyous, fulfilled lives.
When viewed from this perspective, CI doesn't seem so extreme. Any program that gives young people more power, choice and autonomy over their own lives is a positive approach. Children are far more worthy of our trust than we commonly believe is possible.
Our current model of education began in the late 1800s, based on the Prussian model whose purpose was to train children to be compliant, unthinking factory workers. Most people agree children today need to be innovative, creative thinkers and problem-solvers who relate well with others.
The biggest danger I see in CI is to use "child choice" as a motivational tool to more effectively manipulate children to do what we want them to do — namely, be better test-takers.
Using a child's natural desire to succeed and please adults as a means to better control him insults his humanity and undermines any authentic connection we have with him.
I wish the Mountain View Whisman School District much success as they develop new understanding and skills in bringing out the innate potential in children. May they use their ability to look beneath the surface of their actions for guidance and to let their heart and deep regard for children be their guide.
This story contains 534 words.
Stories older than 90 days are available only to subscribing members. Please help sustain quality local journalism by becoming a subscribing member today.
If you are already a subscriber, please log in so you can continue to enjoy unlimited access to stories and archives. Subscriptions start at $5 per month and may be cancelled at any time.