Save the Annex or risk flooding the hospital? | September 16, 2011 | Mountain View Voice | Mountain View Online |

Mountain View Voice

News - September 16, 2011

Save the Annex or risk flooding the hospital?

Council set to make tough decision on flood protection next month

by Daniel DeBolt

In early October the City Council will be asked to either protect the El Camino Hospital area in a major flood or keep a flood basin out of one the city's last pieces of untouched open space.

Pleasing the vocal opponents of the plan, the Santa Clara Valley Water District has declared the controversial proposed flood basin at the Cuesta Annex unnecessary to meet the goals of its Permanente Creek flood protection project. But district officials warn that a new alternative — a "catchment pipe" under Cuesta Drive — would allow flooding of a residential area south of Cuesta Drive where the Annex basin would otherwise provide some protection.

The water district now proposes an option for an 11-foot-deep, 4-acre flood basin at the Cuesta Annex, replacing the 22-foot-deep, 4.5-acre basin that was previously proposed. Several large trees would be kept that would have been removed in the previous plan, angering proponents of keeping the untouched piece of open space as-is.

Annex basin or not, flood basins at McKelvey Park and Rancho San Antonio remain in the water district's plans.

The Annex basin would cost $7 million more than the catchment pipe option, water district engineer Afshin Rouhani said. The pipe could run under Cuesta Drive or another street running east-west north of Permanente Creek's diversion channel to Steven's Creek.

As the Voice reported Aug. 5, a new look at Permanente Creek's hydrology found that 100-year flooding of Permanente Creek will not be as bad as previously thought.

Dam alternative dropped

When the Blach School flood basin was removed from the plan by Los Altos school officials in January, the district was spurred to take a look at an area near the Lehigh Quarry where a dam could be built on Permanente Creek instead. That's when a 300-acre area previously thought to drain into the creek was found actually drain into Lehigh's several-hundred-foot-deep quarry pit, reducing projected creek flows in a flood by 10 percent.

In addition to making the Annex basin unnecessary to met the project's goal of providing flood protection north of El Camino Real, the change in hydrology has also caused the water district to drop the option of building a dam at the quarry, which would have disturbed wildlife habitat, including that of the rare red-legged frog.

"The changed hydrology makes the dam less effective," Rouhani said. "There's less that the dam would capture in the upper watershed."

A date for the City Council meeting on Permanente Creek flood protection is not set in stone, but is expected to occur in early October.

Email Daniel DeBolt at


There are no comments yet for this post