|
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
|
Stock is rarely the star of the plate, yet it determines almost everything that follows. As the quiet architecture behind soups, sauces, braises, grains, and vegetables —stock lends quality not through boldness, but through balance, depth, and integrity. While many cooks reach for boxed broth as a convenience, not all commercial stocks are created equal. Some deliver the slow-simmered character of a traditional kitchen; others rely on salt and flavor enhancers to imitate it. So what is the best boxed soup stock?
We set out to taste test and evaluate several widely available grocery store brands side by side, approaching them warmed and unseasoned. The goal wasn’t simply to decide which tasted best on its own, but to determine which products truly function as a culinary foundation — capable of supporting the dish rather than just filling a pot. When the foundation is right, every dish built on it has a better chance of succeeding.
How We Tasted
Brands were selected from Bianchini’s from Portola Valley and online. Once heated, tastes were served in identical cups with no added salt or seasoning. All brands came in aseptic cartons—all approximately 32OZ.
Stocks were judged on the following criteria:
- Aroma and appearance
- Body & mouthfeel
- Flavor depth
- Salt balance
- Clean finish
The Competitors
- Brand Name: Aneto
First Impression: White, milky appearance. Free-range chickens
Flavor & Body: Silky texture. Salt overwhelms flavor
Sodium content: 1 cup = 750mg
Price: $8.50 – Amazon (pack of 6)
Best Culinary Use: Salt content is too strong for reduced sauces, best in soup with added vegetables and possibly diluted with water. You need to depend on strong seasonings to compete with this stock.
2. Brand Name: Kitchen Basics
First Impression: Deep yellow hue with strong clarity, clean chicken aroma
Flavor & Body: Light bodied, pleasant taste, clean finish. Tastes most like chicken of the 5 samples. Surprising flavors from a low sodium option.
Sodium content: 1 cup = 90 mg
Price: $4.19 – Amazon
Best Culinary Use: This stock is a winner for soups or reduction sauces. Rich deep flavor coming from seasonings and not just salt.
3. Brand Name: Imagine (organic -low sodium)
First Impression: semi milky appearance, attractive aroma, free-range chickens
Flavor & Body: lightest body of all 5 brands. Finish was clean but flavor is lacking—bland
Sodium content: 1 cup = 90 mg
Price: $3.77 – Amazon (pack of 6)
Best Culinary Use: The light texture and flavor are well suited as a cooking liquid for whole grains. Lighter stock textures result in less sticky/gummy grains. Consider other brands for soups and sauces.
4. Brand Name: Pacific (organic)
First Impression: Lovely color and aroma – best chicken-y aroma
Flavor & Body: silky texture, strong personality, but salt distracts from complexity of flavor
Sodium content: 1 cup = 530 mg
Price: $6.00 Amazon
Best Culinary Use: due to salt and body— this stock is better suited for soups than reductions. A reduced sauce would be too influenced by its strong essence.
5. Brand Name: Aneto (low sodium)
First Impression: white milky color with fat dotted on top. Free-range chickens
Flavor & Body: light body and flavor.
Sodium content: 1 cup = 140 mg
Price: $11.71 – Amazon (pack of 6)
Best Culinary Use: Good for sauces, able to be reduced without overwhelming your dish. Good for well-seasoned soups – this stock needs other flavors to carry it through.
What Surprised Us
We wanted to test stocks with various levels of salt to discover how sodium masks or enhances flavor. We were very surprised that the stock with the lowest amount of added salt was the most complex option, performing more like homemade. Added sodium in these particular brands interfered with final results. I’m choosing “low-sodium” from now on.
So Which Box Should You Reach For?
Best Overall: Kitchen Basics—an amazing amount of flavor with lowest amount of added sodium. Beautiful rich color.
Best Low Sodium: Aneto—seasoning could be built up in this stock, but a good choice for sauces where you don’t want the stock to compete with the finished sauce.
Best for everyday cooking: Homemade. Nothing compares to DIY stock. Review What’s Up Stock? for good practices on ways to improve your own.
Stock is the invisible master in the kitchen. Well healed pantries always have some on hand to deglaze with, if nothing else. DIY taste tests are a valuable tool to truly understand what you like and don’t like.
It’s a great excuse to invite a few friends over and host your own Food Party!
