Editorial: TCE mystery is (nearly) solved


After many years of watching and reporting about EPA scientists and others tracking the underground migration of the toxic chemical trichloroethylene (TCE) from leaking tanks in the vicinity of N. Whisman Road to the discovery of other "hot spots" hundreds, if not thousands of feet away, it is remarkable that even today, the extent of TCE contamination in the city's soil and groundwater remains unclear.

The latest thinking, though there is no conclusive proof yet, is that it is very likely that the mystery of how TCE managed to flow west of what was thought to be its boundaries has been solved.

It has long been known that the solvent that was spilled at the Fairchild plant on N. Whisman Road, and at other plants making computer chips, created an underground plume of contamination that appeared to be contained in an area bordered by E. Middlefield Road, Ellis Street and N. Whisman Road, and extending across Highway 101 north to connect with another large TCE plume left by the Navy at Moffett Field.

Then came the surprising discovery in 1982 that a deep well used by Joe Silva and his family for drinking water and in their farming operation was contaminated by TCE , in an area outside what was thought to be the boundary of the plume. The well on the Sherland Avenue property is about a block west of the MEW and was immediately shut down when it tested positive for high levels of TCE. But despite efforts to determine how the dangerous chemical found its way into a deep (465 feet) well, the mystery of how the chemical migrated over half a block west of what were thought to be its boundaries was never solved.

In late 2013 two more "hot spots" were found by EPA testing on Evandale Avenue, also west of the N. Whisman boundary of the MEW, and also along a sewer line. Two other significant hot spots of TCE were found even farther west, along the same sewer line, which makes it a near certainty that when early tech workers at Fairchild or other plants making computer chips poured TCE down the drain it found its way through sewer line connections, and produced vapors found by the EPA in a handful of homes in the area. More could be discovered if the Environmental Protection Agency continues to test along the sewer lines in the residential neighborhood west of Whisman Road, where small amounts of TCE have already been found along sewer lines on Easy Street and Tyrella Avenue, among others.

The latest discoveries show how little is known about this dangerous toxic chemical's presence in the city. It can seem contained in the North Whisman area and then be discovered blocks away, where in some cases, residents have lived with it in their homes for more than 40 years.

What is known is that prolonged breathing of the toxic vapors given off by underground plumes of TCE can cause birth defects, cancer and a host of other diseases, although it is nearly impossible to attribute individual cases of diseases directly to inhalation of TCE vapors in this area. And unless barriers have been installed in a home's foundation, TCE vapors from undiscovered hot spots have the potential to penetrate into living spaces, potentially exposing residents to increased health risks.

Another, more problematic hot spot, is the site of a large former military apartment complex -- Orion Park -- just outside the main gate at Moffett Field, torn down in 2009 and once home to hundreds of military families. A TCE plume in the ground water could have exposed families who lived in the apartments to toxic TCE fumes since 1968. The situation has eased somewhat since demolition of the complex, which was replaced by offices and training facilities. The Army contends that the since the area was a farm prior to 1968, cleanup of the TCE is not its responsibility.

But that conclusion was made before the recent discoveries, which strongly suggest that sewer lines are the conduits of TCE outside the MEW area. Lenny Siegel, a longtime local watchdog of toxic cleanups, told the Voice he has discovered a map showing a large sewer line located on the east side of Orion Park that had also once served Fairchild, where the TCE is said to have originated. No one knows for sure if the apartments were contaminated by the gas, but the discovery of TCE on the Orion site is certainly an indicator that some apartment-dwellers were breathing the toxic fumes for a long time.

It is remarkable that after so many years, residents and city officials are seeing strong evidence that TCE apparently migrated along sewer line corridors to sites far beyond the boundaries in the MEW. Now it is incumbent on the EPA to do more testing, using the sewer line maps to guide them, and for the city to fully cooperate in revealing the locations and flow directions of sewer lines then and now. It is difficult to imagine why no one suspected the sewer line's importance in tracking the spread of this dangerous chemical, but now it is clear that TCE can travel hundreds, if not thousands, of feet away from what was previously thought to be its definitive boundaries. And although TCE's half-life in open air is only about seven days, depending on conditions it is a stable compound underground and could last for 100 or more years.

— Tom Gibboney

What is democracy worth to you?
Support local journalism.


3 people like this
Posted by Juan
a resident of Whisman Station
on Jan 14, 2014 at 2:12 pm

Who if anyone is responsible for this?

3 people like this
Posted by Focus on the Solution
a resident of The Crossings
on Jan 14, 2014 at 2:36 pm

The responsible people are from a company that has not existed for about, what, 40 years? Not sure any are still alive, and since they broke no laws at the time, what should be done to them anyway?

3 people like this
Posted by Jeff
a resident of Old Mountain View
on Jan 14, 2014 at 3:40 pm

Responsibility was certainly dealt with to a good degree. The MEW was an EPA Superfund site, with Fairchild, Intel and Raytheon spending tens of millions of dollars on various approved remediation efforts beginning in the 1980s. This program was of course based on the tech and science of the time. A major problem was and is that the subsurface hydrogeology of that area is quite jumbled, and it is very hard to find and remove every bit of the contamination. The remediation wells, for example, were intended to remove what was described as source contamination, not being able to provide control of a broad area. Many of the lines denoting how much TCE is where were based on extrapolations, not on clearly continuous data. If TCE went through sewers due to dumping, or followed sewer line trenches, it is sadly no surprise that it had escaped previous detection. One has to guess that this migration through other than natural means could help explain the Silva well.

The "merged plume" from MEW sources - the above named companies, not just Fairchild - went under Highway 101 into the Moffett area. It is also established that the Navy used TCE to wash down aircraft, the waste material ran off and much went into the ground under the aviation facility.

You can see pretty much all of these issues spoken to in the public comments, including some of the current players, back in the 2004 public comments on the then-draft EPA 5-Year Cleanup Review Report: Web Link That was after about twenty years of study and effort, and nearly ten years ago.

3 people like this
Posted by Old Ben
a resident of Shoreline West
on Jan 20, 2014 at 10:17 am

Is anyone conducting any sort of health survey to determine whether this TCE plume has, in fact, triggered disease clusters in Mountain View? Specifically, leukemia, birth defects, and polycythemia vera.

Your million-dollar home might not be worth a dime.

Sorry, but further commenting on this topic has been closed.

Stay informed

Get daily headlines sent straight to your inbox.

Chick-fil-A quietly starts delivering out of DoorDash kitchen in Redwood City
By Elena Kadvany | 50 comments | 9,044 views

Palo Altans and their Virtue Signaling
By Sherry Listgarten | 23 comments | 2,396 views

Differentiating Grief from Clinical Depression
By Chandrama Anderson | 0 comments | 2,121 views